Gift Cards, Store Credit, or Giveaways: What’s the Best Way to Reward Employees?

By Matt English

Published May 1, 2019

Last updated November 3, 2026

If you want employees to actually use and wear what you give them, store credit in a company store usually works best. Gift cards give people the most freedom, but they do nothing for your brand and the IRS treats them like cash. One-item giveaways are the simplest to run, but much of what gets handed out goes unused.

Many of our clients ask us the best way to get branded gear and rewards into employees’ hands. Every company is different, but our clients’ experience shows some methods work much better than others. Here’s how the three most common options compare.

Quick comparison

One-item giveawayGift cardStore credit in a company store
Who picks the itemThe companyThe employee (any store)The employee (from your branded catalog)
Promotes your brandYesNoYes
Risk of unused itemsHighLowLow
Cost controlFixed order up frontFixed per cardSet per person; unredeemed credit isn’t spent
Tax treatment (US)Low-value, occasional gifts may be non-taxableTaxable, like cashDepends on value and frequency; ask your tax advisor
Admin effortOrdering, storing and shipping stockBuying and sending cardsSetting up the store once, then loading credit

Option 1: Give everyone the same item

A manager picks one item, orders a large quantity, keeps it in stock and hands it out.

  • Pros: full control over what’s given and how it looks. Easy to plan for a single event.
  • Cons: one person makes every decision. Employees who don’t like the item may never use it, and the leftover stock takes up storage space.

This works best for event giveaways or when everyone truly needs the same thing, like a uniform.

Option 2: Gift cards for employees

Gift cards let employees spend a set amount wherever they like.

  • Pros: employees get real choice, and cards are quick to buy and send, including to remote staff.
  • Cons: the reward does nothing for your brand or culture once it’s spent. And in the US, gift cards count as taxable income.

The IRS says cash and cash-equivalent items “are never excludable from income,” and a gift card for general merchandise is a cash equivalent. That means a $50 gift card is reported as wages, just like a $50 bonus. (IRS: De minimis fringe benefits)

So the best gift cards for employees are often the ones that come with a personal thank-you, given for a clear reason.

Option 3: Store credit in a company store

With store credit, each employee gets a set amount to spend in your own branded online store. There are two ways to set it up:

  1. Credit for specific items. Employees get a code to redeem one item or a group of items you choose. People who don’t want it don’t redeem it, so no money is wasted. The trade-off is less choice.
  2. Credit for anything in the store. Employees get a credit amount and choose whatever they want from your catalog. In our clients’ experience, this is the most successful method. Employees pick exactly what they’ll use, so they use it regularly. Many save their credit for an item they really want, or add their own money for something bigger.
  • Pros: employees choose, your brand gets worn, and you only pay for what’s redeemed.
  • Cons: it takes an initial setup, so you’ll need a store with products, budgets and shipping in place.

In Axomo, admins can set up recurring store credit and make bulk credit deposits, so rewards for milestones, holidays or new hires can run on a schedule. See how to set up an online company apparel store for employees for the steps.

How to choose

Many companies combine methods: a welcome kit on day one, then store credit for milestones and recognition.

FAQ

Are gift cards a good reward for employees?

They’re good for flexibility and speed. But they’re taxable like cash in the US and don’t build any connection to your company. They work best as an occasional thank-you, not as your whole rewards program.

Are gift cards taxable for employees?

Yes, in the US. The IRS treats gift cards for general merchandise as cash equivalents, so their value is taxable wages no matter how small. Check with your payroll or tax advisor for your situation.

Is branded swag taxable for employees?

It depends. The IRS lists occasional, low-value holiday gifts as an example of a non-taxable de minimis benefit, and looks at both how often and how much. It sets no fixed dollar limit, but notes it has ruled that items over $100 could not be de minimis.

What is store credit for employees?

It’s a balance an employee can spend in the company’s branded online store. The company sets the amount and the catalog, and the employee chooses the items.

Can you use store credit and gift cards together?

Yes. Some teams use store credit for branded gear and milestones, and save gift cards for one-off thank-yous.

Share This Post